Shielded vs. Sealed Bearings: Differences, Types, and How to Choose
Introduction
Bearings are the critical joints in machinery, ensuring smooth motion and efficiency. However, to maintain peak performance and extend lifespan, they require robust protection against contaminants and lubricant loss.
This is where the choice between bearing seals and shields becomes essential. Are you struggling with selecting the best bearing for a high-speed application or a dusty environment? In this guide, we will break down the key differences between shielded vs. sealed bearings, explore various bearing seal types, and provide a clear evaluation to help you decide which protection is right for your specific needs.
Selection Summary: Which One Do You Need?
-
Choose Shields (ZZ) if your machine runs at very high RPM and operates in a relatively dry, clean area (e.g., electric motors, fans).
-
Choose Seals (2RS) if your machine faces dust, water, or mud and runs at moderate speeds (e.g., agricultural machinery, conveyor belts, automotive hubs).
What Are Bearing Seals and Shields?
Bearing Seals (The “Contact” Solution)
Bearing seals (often designated with suffixes like 2RS, RS, or DDU, such as the BS2-2218-2RS/VT143) are typically manufactured from flexible materials like Nitrile rubber (NBR) or Viton. These seals are designed to fit snugly into the outer ring and make physical contact with the inner ring.
This contact creates a tight barrier (“contact seal”) that is highly effective at preventing lubricant leakage and blocking fine contaminants like dust, water, and moisture. Because of this tight fit, rubber bearing seals offer the highest level of protection but generate slightly more friction, which can limit maximum rotational speed.
Bearing Shields (The “Non-Contact” Solution)
Bearing shields (identified by suffixes like ZZ, 2Z, or Z, such as the 6202 ZZC3) are simple metal plates, usually made of steel or stainless steel. Unlike seals, shields are stamped into the outer ring and create a narrow gap with the inner ring without touching it.
Because they are non-contact, metal shield bearings generate virtually no friction, making them the ideal choice for high-speed applications. While they effectively deflect larger debris (like rocks or wood chips), they are less effective than rubber seals at keeping out fine dust or moisture.
Sealed vs. Shielded Bearings: Key Differences
To choose the right bearing, you must understand the trade-offs between protection and performance. The main difference lies in the structure and how it impacts friction and speed.
Comparison Table: Rubber Seal (2RS) vs. Metal Shield (ZZ)
| Feature | Bearing Seals (2RS/DDU) | Bearing Shields (ZZ/2Z) |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Nitrile Rubber (NBR), Viton | Steel Sheet (SPCC/SECC) |
| Contact Type | Contact (Touches inner ring) | Non-Contact (Gap exists) |
| Friction & Torque | High (Due to contact) | Low (Zero contact friction) |
| Speed Limit | Low to Moderate | High (Same as open bearings) |
| Dust Protection | Excellent (Blocks fine dust) | Good (Blocks large particles) |
| Water Resistance | Good (Resists splashes) | Poor (Not water-resistant) |
Structure & Material
-
Seals (Rubber): Made from synthetic rubber bonded to a steel insert for strength. They are flexible and possess a sealing lip that firmly contacts the inner ring.
-
Shields (Metal): Made from stamped sheet steel. They are rigid, non-removable in some cases, and maintain a small clearance gap from the inner ring to avoid contact.
Performance: Friction and Speed
-
Seals: Because the rubber lip rubs against the inner ring, seals generate friction. This friction creates heat, which limits the bearing’s maximum rotational speed. Seals are best for slow to medium-speed applications.
-
Shields: Since the metal shield does not touch the moving inner ring, there is no added friction. This allows shielded bearings to operate at high speeds (comparable to open bearings) and lower operating temperatures.
Protection Capabilities
-
Seals (Best for Dirty/Wet Environments): The contact design provides a hermetic seal. They are the only choice if your application involves exposure to water, moisture, or fine dust.
-
Shields (Best for Clean/Dry Environments): Shields act as a “baffle.” They act as a labyrinth to deflect larger debris like wood chips or pebbles but cannot stop liquids or microscopic dust from entering.
Common Bearing Seal Failures & Troubleshooting
Seal Dislodgement (Seal Popping Out)
-
The Problem: The seal pushes out of its groove during operation.
-
Why It Happens: This is often caused by over-lubrication (too much grease creates internal pressure) or high vibration.
-
The Fix: Avoid over-greasing. If high pressure is unavoidable, switch to a bearing with a crimped metal shield (ZZ) or a specially designed high-pressure seal.
Excessive Friction & Overheating
-
The Problem: The bearing feels hot to the touch or won’t rotate freely (high torque).
-
Why It Happens: You might be using a contact rubber seal (2RS) in a high-speed application. The friction from the rubber lip rubbing against the inner ring generates heat.
-
The Fix: Check your RPM. For high-speed applications (>10,000 RPM), switch to a non-contact metal shield (ZZ) or a non-contact rubber seal (VV type) to eliminate friction.
Contaminant Ingress (Dust/Water Getting In)
-
The Problem: The bearing sounds gritty, noisy, or seizes up.
-
Why It Happens: The seal lip may be damaged, inverted during installation, or simply not robust enough for the environment.
-
The Fix:
* Installation: Ensure you don’t push the seal inward when mounting the bearing.
* Selection: If working in wet or muddy conditions, standard shields (ZZ) are useless. Upgrade to heavy-duty contact seals (DDU/3-Lip seals) for maximum protection.
Seal Lip Wear (Leakage)
-
The Problem: Lubricant is leaking out of the bearing.
-
Why It Happens: Natural wear and tear over time, or the shaft surface is too rough (if the seal touches the shaft).
-
The Fix: Inspect the seal lip for hardening or cracking. If the environment is extremely hot, standard NBR rubber may be melting. Consider upgrading to Viton (FKM) seals for high-temperature resistance.
Best Practices for Bearing Seal Installation & Maintenance
Ensure a Contaminant-Free Environment
-
Before installation, clean the shaft and housing thoroughly. Even microscopic dust trapped behind a bearing seal can migrate inside and degrade the grease.
-
Pro Tip: Do not remove the bearing from its packaging until the very last moment.
Use Proper Fitting Tools (No Direct Impact)
-
Never strike a bearing directly with a hammer. This can dent the metal shield or dislodge the rubber seal.
-
Instead, use a bearing fitting tool kit or an arbor press. Always apply pressure to the ring that has the tight fit (usually the inner ring for shaft mounting) to avoid transmitting force through the rolling elements.
Verify Chemical Compatibility
-
If you are re-greasing a bearing with removable seals, ensure the new lubricant is compatible with the seal material.
-
For example, some synthetic lubricants can attack standard Nitrile (NBR) seals, causing them to swell or crack. In such cases, Viton seals may be required.
Inspect for Seal Integrity
-
Visually inspect the seal lip for tears or deformations before mounting. Ensure the seal is seated evenly in the groove. A “cocked” or uneven seal will drag against the cage, creating friction and heat.
Pros and Cons: Metal Shields vs. Rubber Seals
Metal Shields (ZZ / 2Z)
(Best for: High Speed, Clean & Dry Environments)
The Pros (Advantages):
-
Zero Friction: Since the metal shield does not touch the inner ring, it enables the bearing to run at maximum speed without generating heat.
-
Maintenance Free: Ideal for “greased-for-life” applications where re-lubrication isn’t needed.
-
Durability: The steel shield is rigid and withstands impacts better than soft rubber.
The Cons (Disadvantages):
-
No Water Protection: Metal shields are NOT water-tight. They cannot stop moisture, steam, or liquids from entering the raceway.
-
Fine Dust Ingress: While they block large debris (pebbles, grit), microscopic dust can still penetrate the gap over time.
Rubber Seals (2RS / DDU)
(Best for: Wet, Dirty, or Harsh Environments)
The Pros (Advantages):
-
Superior Sealing: The contact lip creates a tight barrier, keeping lubricant in and locking contaminants out. This is the standard choice for general machinery.
-
Water Resistance: Excellent protection against water splashes, humidity, and washdowns.
-
Versatile: Available in different materials (like Viton/FKM) for high-temperature resistance.
The Cons (Disadvantages):
-
Speed Limits: The friction from the rubber lip rubbing against the inner ring generates heat, which limits the bearing’s top speed.
-
Torque: Higher starting torque implies slightly more energy is required to rotate the bearing.
-
Material Degradation: Rubber can harden or crack over time if exposed to harsh chemicals or extreme ozone levels (unlike steel shields).
Real-World Application Guide: Which Seal Fits Your Industry?
Electric Motors & Fans (High Speed, Clean)
-
Recommended: Metal Shields (ZZ / 2Z)
-
Why: These applications require high RPM and low heat generation. Since the environment is usually enclosed and relatively clean, the non-contact shield provides sufficient protection without sacrificing speed.
Agricultural & Construction Machinery (Slow, Dirty, Wet)
-
Recommended: Rubber Contact Seals (2RS / DDU)
-
Why: Tractors and excavators operate in mud, dust, and rain. A metal shield would fail instantly here. You need a tight rubber seal to block water and abrasive dirt, even if it limits the bearing’s rotation speed.
Conveyor Systems & Hubs (Moderate Speed, General Use)
-
Recommended: Contact Seals (2RS) or Non-Contact Seals (VV)
-
Why: For conveyor belts in factories, keeping the grease inside the bearing is just as important as keeping dust out. Rubber seals ensure the factory floor stays clean and the bearing stays lubricated for years.
Conclusion: Selecting the Best Bearing for Your Application
Choosing between shielded vs. sealed bearings isn’t just a minor detail—it’s a decision that directly impacts the lifespan of your equipment and maintenance costs.
To summarize the evaluation process:
-
Go with Metal Shields (ZZ) if your priority is high speed, low friction, and the environment is relatively clean or only has large debris.
-
Go with Rubber Seals (2RS/DDU) if your priority is maximum protection against moisture, water, fine dust, or if you need to lock grease in for the long haul.
Still Unsure? Let the Experts Help
Every application is unique. Whether you are designing a high-speed motor or heavy-duty agricultural machinery, selecting the wrong seal type can lead to overheating or premature failure.
Don’t leave your machinery’s performance to chance. At TFL Bearing, we specialize in high-precision bearings with customized sealing solutions.
-
Need a specific bearing seal type?
-
Looking for a custom bearing solution?
[Contact Our Engineering Team Today] or [Browse Our Full Catalog of Ball Bearings] to find the perfect match for your project.